My name is Kathleen, and I have been researching my family history since I was a child. I love to go into county courthouses and smell the old books and paper... or is it dust? This blog will focus on the stories I've heard over the years and the research methods I follow. I am particularly interested in data management and cloud genealogy.

Some of my personal areas of interest include Southern Maryland and DC (Robie, Rhodes, Grimes, Lindsey), NY state (Hill, Cookingham, Flynn, Rhodes, Skinner, Wheeler, Mead, Havens, Trotter), NJ (Parcell), North Carolina and Eastern TN (Lynch, Seabolt, Spears), MO (Wilcox, Kiddell), and CA (Simi, Grady)

I am always happy to compare notes or share my experiences, so please leave a comment!

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

The need for standards in evidence... or why I abandoned commercial genealogy software

They do try...  Family tree software programs used by genealogists often pay lip service to good research practices by assigning a check box for the user to indicate whether a given source is "primary" or "secondary;" sometimes they include a rating system where you assign 5 stars to a "really good" source... whatever that means. 


Unfortunately it is all but useless to the average user who is faced with classifying sources that aren't easily categorized:   a digital copy of an original land record published by a state archives, an abstract of a chapter on your great-great grandfather from a local history published in 1882 and reprinted on a Rootsweb message board, a photo of a tombstone, and so on.  The definitions are sometimes hard to remember, too.... why isn't that chapter on my 2nd g-grandfather a primary source?  It has loads of direct information about him!


Without guidelines it is really hard for a non-academic researcher to assign surety levels in a way that will be commonly understood by other researchers. I just read a brilliant article by Elizabeth Shown Mills defining standards for evaluating and using historical evidence (you can read it here). She identifies three qualities of evidence that establish their credibility:
1)  whether the form of the data is original or derivative,  2) whether the specific data is from an informant with first hand (primary) or secondary knowledge of the matter under consideration, and 3) whether that data represents direct or indirect evidence of the date, name, place, event or circumstance we are trying to prove.  

Recently I set out to create a database application that would allow me to manage my research, and -- most importantly -- track the quality of the evidence I am gathering.  The criteria identified by Dr. Mills can be described as "objective" - that is, the evidence in question either meets or does not meet the definition.  This is key to providing guidelines that can be widely used by researchers with different levels of experience.  This is also key to my Genealogical Research System.   Rather than focus on adding names to a tree, I start with the assumption that sources are the primary points of interest, and accordingly, it is important to track information about the quality of the physical source itself.  My database tool allows the researcher to record each piece of evidence contained in a source and note the quality of that evidence relative to research objectives.  

I've just updated the field names in the analysis page of my Evidence library to more accurately reflect the terms used by Dr. Mills (so the templates I uploaded to the Bento template exchange are now officially out of date).  Specifically, I've added a checkbox field called "Original source," which the user will check if the source qualifies as an original (actual document or digital copy from reputable source) vs. a derivative.  The Source table is supplied to remind you of how the source you examined was formatted. The "Direct evidence" checkbox is checked if the data represents a statement of fact that explicitly supports the evidence, as opposed to data that only provides circumstantial evidence.  The "Primary Informant" checkbox is checked if the person supplying the information in the source did so from direct knowledge of the event.


By recording objective information about the quality of specific evidence, the researcher can establish a strong foundation for any conclusions to be drawn from that evidence.  This tool also allows users to track their research at every stage in the process, from visits to a repository all the way to final proof of an assertion. As a result, any evidence that is subsequently added to the researcher's family tree software will be supported by more objective measurements of value than the program would otherwise allow.

see Elizabeth Shown Mills, “Working with Historical Evidence: Genealogical Principles and Standards,” Evidence: A Special Issue of the National Genealogical Society Quarterly 87 (September 1999): 165–84; digital image at Elizabeth Shown Mills, Historic Pathways (http://www.HistoricPathways.com : accessed 16 May 2012).

Thursday, May 10, 2012

My Genealogical Research System.... explained


Yesterday I wrote about the system I created in Bento that completely changes how I manage my genealogy research process.  There are a few other templates such as mine out there, but I like how mine uses Bento's digital media capabilities, allowing me to take full advantage of all the multimedia resources available for genealogists.  I have uploaded the templates to Bento, but I don't know how long they take to vet them, so please contact me by leaving a comment on the blog if you are interested in getting a copy.

My hope is that these research templates may inspire the genealogical software programmers to create products that work in the same way that a researcher works:  start with the research and end with the conclusions.  All these years the companies have been creating programs that work backward, encouraging people to enter conclusions before they have analyzed the results of their research.  My dream program will be family tree software that includes a research module, so you have a place to record and evaluate the data you uncover until you are confident enough to attach it to an individual.

I set out to create an integrated system.  Many of the fields in one library (i.e., data files) are related to those in other libraries, so you never have to input data more than once and you can often view data that exists in one library as a reference field in another.  The fact that data can be input in one library and available in another means you don't have to interrupt your work flow to take notes or make changes.
Opening the folder labeled Genealogical Research System you will see a page of icons representing each of the 11 libraries in the system.  You can click on any one to open that library and begin working.


You can see that some of the icons have slightly different looks than the others.  I've used different themes to represent the various functions of each library. The primary modules are the Sources, Evidence, To Do List, Genealogy_photos, and Genealogy_artifacts libraries.  These cover the essential tasks of recording research trips and the research process itself, along with keeping track of all the little tasks that arise along the way.  (The photos and artifacts libraries are modeled after user-submitted templates already in the Bento template exchange, but they are included here because I have adapted them to my record-keeping methods and have related them to other libraries in my system.)
The libraries called Repositories, Genealogy_people, Hardcopy File Number, and Online Databases are basically look-up lists that you can either populate in advance or on the go, but in either case are used to augment the information you acquire in the research process and create relationships among the data.  I've given the Correspondence library its own theme because it supplements research.  Bento allows you to send emails directly from the program if you use the Mac OS X Mail application.  I don't use it, so I create digital copies of my emails and store them in this library, but obviously this could be adjusted should you use Apple mail.  The Research Logs library is one I don't use much anymore, since I can accomplish the same thing by running a search on the Source library (more on that below).
Another thing to know before I get into the details is that some libraries contain more than one data entry form.  In the Sources library, for example, I have one form to enter data from an online source and another one to use when examining a source in person.  You need to capture slightly different bits of information for each type of source, and having more than one form means that the input page only has to have the required fields and no others.
Let's take a look at the libraries in detail:
** Sources

This library is the heart of the entire system.  There are three forms you can use for entering data about a source.  
1. The first is for sources examined in person: 
  

Here you enter the title, author and relevant publication data for that source.  Select a repository from the related data table "Repository;" this table contains records from the Repositories library.  You can add a new record or select one or more existing records .  
There are a series of fields describing the source itself, which together help you qualify the source.  The "media type" field asks you to describe the source's physical format (book, digital/online, document, index, microfilm, microfiche, photocopy, or mp3 file).  The "source type" field describes the distance of the source from the original (abstract, extract, index, original index, original register, official copy from government files, original form, original duplicate, transcript).  The "source category" describes the original purpose of the source (burial, census, church, court, directory, land, lists, military, newspaper, vital record, wills, other).   These distinctions are important -- examining an original will in a courthouse may yield very different information from what you would get from a photocopied abstract of the same will from a clipping file in a library.
There are fields to enter your search objective for the source, any notes, and related data files.  Sometimes I have digital images of either the source or my notes, and I'll put them in this file.
2. The second form in the Sources library is for entering online sources.


This is similar to regular source entry, but you can link your source to a database in the Online Databases library rather than to a physical repository.
3. The third form in the Sources library is for noting whether or not this source contained useful evidence.  


When entering data, all you have to do is check the box asking if there is evidence from this source.  Doing this (or not) will allow you to run a search in the Sources library for any sources that are unused.  You don't have to enter the evidence here.  Later, when you add the data from this source into the Evidence library, you will link back to this source, and that action will automatically populate this table in the Sources library.
Smart Lists
The Sources library also includes three smart lists.  Smart lists are basically queries of your data that you set up for a particular library.  They are "smart" because Bento constantly updates the response to the query as you input or change data in that library.  I've set up a "Finding Aids" smart list, to identify just those sources that are indexes or other finding aids to sources, but which themselves do not contain actual data.  The second smart list returns "sources without evidence," a search on all the sources I've examined that did not contain evidence I could use in my research.  The third smart list searches for any source that includes an entry in the "database used" field, in other words, all online sources.  You can run queries in Bento on any field except "related data" field types, i.e., those fields that are linked to other libraries.  To avoid this problem,  I include a new field to enter that information in the current library wherever I include a "related data" field. 
**Evidence
There are four forms in this library.
1. The first form, Transcript of evidence, is where you enter information from your source that corresponds to specific information about an individual that was gleaned from the source.  


The field "Evidence (title)" is where you enter a phrase that summarizes this evidence.  I add a relevant locality so when I want to search the database at a later time, I can focus my search on the appropriate area.  I select the source I used for this evidence from the "Source" table, which links to more details about the source in the Sources library.  If the source contains many pieces of evidence, I will want to include publication details about exactly where I found this piece of evidence (such as the page or volume number).  If I have a paper copy of the data to file, I will add a new record to the Hardcopy lookup table and enter that number and filing category.  Everyone has their own filing methods, I know, but I find that it is simpler to file by type of record plus a consecutive number -- it is very quick and easy to process new material this way.  I always know where everything can be found because Macs have a powerful search engine and I am careful to log my paper files into the computer.
In this digital age, though, there are more ways to have my data at hand from within Bento itself.  I have created a field to enter notes directly from the source into the "transcript of source" field.  You can drag and drop a digital file from your computer into the "digital notes" field, which allows you to double click the icon to open the file in whatever program created it.  Or, you can just drop the a link to your data in the "data URL" field.  Just click on it and Bento will open the link.
2.  The second form, Evidence Analysis, is another important step in assessing your data, and one that often gets postponed in the thrill of the hunt for more data. 


In this form, there are text fields for discussing the nature of the evidence and your level of confidence in it based on the source it comes from and whether it is considered to be primary or secondary and direct or indirect evidence. There are checkboxes to identify these qualities.  You will also see a table called "Evidence related to whom."  This table contains  related data from the Genealogy_people library, from which you can select the individuals who are connected to that evidence.  The table labeled "confidence level of source" shows information from the related source (i.e., media type, source type, etc.) that can help you assess the quality of the evidence based on the quality of the source.
3.  The third form, Evidence Analysis/uncertain connections, is the same as the second form; it just adds a checkbox indicating that you are not certain whether or not the evidence relates to a particular person.


4.  The fourth form, Add 'To Do' task, is a page where you can add related tasks to a 'to do' list.  Entries from this form are usually accessed later via the To Do List library.

There are three smart lists in the Evidence library.  The first, "to copy into Reunion database," selects those records I have identified as being ready to enter into a family tree software (I use Reunion).  The second one, "uncertain connections," selects evidence that I have not yet confirmed as relating to a specific individual.  The third list, "need to find primary sources," identifies data that was gathered from less desirable sources, reminding me to find the original sources.  
**To Do List
There are two forms in this library.  
1. To Do List



This is a straightforward data entry page, where you identify the task itself, the nature of the task (check files and edit computer entries, correspondence, writing, multimedia, research, visit repository, websearch, or visit cemetery), and identify a repository if appropriate.  You can also enter notes, relevant websites, and link to files on your computer.
2. Related data is the second form in the To Do List library.



I added this page just to show you at a glance all the related records in other libraries.  In this example, I know that information relating to Ed Simi and Theodore Grady Jr. & Sr. can be found at the UC Berkely library, with specific finding aids included in my correspondence with the librarian, David Kessler. 
**Correspondence


This library is a simple way to keep track of your correspondence, and, as I noted in my introduction, would be even easier if you use the native Mac email application.  Since I don't, I copy email threads to files on my computer and drag them to the field labeled "correspondence file."  I keep basic contact information for each person I communicate with, and add notes on the family name or topic of our correspondence.
**Genealogy_photos


This library is a simple filing system for family photos, allowing you to track information about the condition and provenance of photos.  There is also a related data field allowing you to select individuals depicted in the photo, as well as a checkbox indicating whether the image should be included in your family tree database (Reunion.)
**Genealogy_artifacts

Similar to the photo library, the artifacts library is a simple filing system to track family heirlooms, their location and provenance.  I have also included a table allowing you to relate the heirloom to a particular person in your database.
**Online Databases


This library is primarily a list that you use from within other libraries to provide information about a source or a task.  The information in this library includes online databases and their URLs.  Any notes about using a particular database can be added as well.  Databases in this library can be ones that you have used as well as those you are interested in trying out.  Also included in this library is a table that shows all the sources you have examined that are linked to any given online database record.
**Hardcopy File Numbers


This is a library I use to generate sequential numbers for my personal filing system.  I have included an Evidence table so I can see at a glance what individual pieces of evidence are included in any given file.
**Genealogy_people

I exported all the names included in my family tree software (Reunion), together with associated birth and death years and person ID numbers into Bento to create a body of people to whom I will relate evidence gathered in my research.  I have included an Evidence table so I can see at a glance what evidence I have found for each person in my database.  If I find a new person connected to my tree in the course of my research, I will first add them to Reunion and then, after obtaining a person ID #, I will also add them to my Bento system.
**Repositories


Like the Online Databases library, the Repositories library is a simple listing of libraries and other repositories with their address and contact information, as well as space to make notes about visiting, usage policies, etc.  I have included a link to the To Do List  library, so I can add a task directly from this screen.
** Research Logs


I used to use this form to enter all the sources I looked at when I visited a repository, whether or not I gathered any data from them.  Now, however, I find it is easier to input sources directly into the Sources library and create research logs by running a search (CMD F) on any one of a number of criteria, such as date of search, repository name, search objective, etc.  I left this library in the system because some people might prefer to have  something they deliberately create as a "log" rather than have to rely on a new search every time you want to generate a log.  

So, in a nutshell, that's how I manage my research -- I hope these templates are helpful to others.  Please don't hesitate to contact me with any questions or comments! I'd love to know if others feel the same way I do about commercial genealogy software.

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

A new tool for genealogical research!

I haven't posted much here lately.... not because I don't love my family history work, but because I've been increasingly frustrated by the research process itself.  Back in the days when everything was on paper, it was relatively easy to stay on top of my research, but over the years we've all gone digital, and that has been a game changer in more ways than one, but mostly because:

Software programs that cater to the genealogist are primarily designed to record family relationships.   

Well, yes, obviously...... so what's wrong with that?  

Genealogy software programs are designed to focus on the end result of research, not the process itself, so most of the work that we do takes place outside of the software.  In most programs, you input data by attaching it to an event in the life of a person in your tree, and only then (if you are thorough) you enter a source for your information.  One of the reasons genealogy is such a fascinating pursuit is the thrill of the hunt.  We are all detectives:  we gather clues, apply logic, and only after careful sifting of the evidence can we come to a conclusion.  The trouble with current software is that there is no place to record the steps you take to reach that conclusion.  I want a program that can manage my research!

When I do family history research, I make an effort to work according to the Genealogical Proof Standard.  My first emphasis is on the source I'm looking at -- I want to record information about its reliability and provenance before I even begin to record any information it may have on my ancestor, and then I want to extract all the potentially relevant evidence it may contain before I assign it to a particular individual.  In other words, there is a lot of information that has to be processed before I can attach any piece of evidence to my family tree, and existing software puts the cart before the horse.

Now, I know that this is not news to people who think about genealogy and technology.  What surprises me, though, is how long it is taking for the people who program commercial software to catch on.  I am somewhat of a database geek, but unfortunately without the technical expertise to program my own software.... so I've done the next best thing.  I've created some templates for an existing database software that I think might be useful to other researchers as well.  I am a Mac user, so I created templates for Filemaker's Bento software, a basic program that, while fairly powerful, it is not complicated to use.

I've just uploaded my Genealogical Research System templates to the Bento template exchange.
The great thing about Bento is that it is very reasonable, about $50, and can be used for any number of data tracking tasks.  I think it is a great tool, and I'm very excited about its application to my genealogy research.  My next blog post will be a detailed explanation of how the system works, so stay tuned!



Thursday, October 6, 2011

There will be a change of help in the Tilden household....

I came across an interesting article in the San Francisco Call the other day while searching for my husband's great-grandfather.  Theodore Grady generated quite a lot of mentions in the newspapers during his lifetime because of his unusual status as a well-educated man with special needs.  He was the first deaf-mute in the state of California to graduate from a college for the hearing (UC Berkeley), and the first deaf man to pass the California bar and work as an attorney.

This particular article really struck home because it highlights how far our society has come in dealing with people with special needs.  Theodore Grady was only a side note in the story, which centered on his friend, the sculptor Douglas Tilden.  Tilden came home late one evening, realized he had forgotten his key and let himself in by a window.  A servant thought he had gone mad and called the police, who hauled him off.  Justly incensed, Tilden was agitated, but because he was mute he couldn't explain himself.   He was given a "quieting potion," and slept it off until his family came to get him the next day.  The story ends with the dry comment: "There will be a change of help in the Tilden household."

 You've just got to read it for yourself in all its glorious wordiness (here's the link if you want to see the original page):

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

Twins are amazing!

How fun is the internet!  Most of the time you go online with a specific task, get the information you need, and you're out of there.  But then there are those days where you are sucked into the black hole, and you come out hours -- or even days -- later with no memory of what you were doing, or where the time went.  Well, it's been my experience that if you don't over think things and just go with the flow, sometimes you get some really good stuff.

Like today.... I was reading emails and somehow got sidetracked to the genealogy posts on the Family Tree Magazine forum page.  This post sparked my curiosity, and with a little more sleuthing, I found the following image on the Library of Congress website:


(click here to see the full image)
The caption read:

Twins become mothers together for second time in less than two years. Washington, D.C., April 7. Accustomed to doing practically the same things all their lives, these Washington twins, now mothers, have apparently decided that having their children together would certainly be in order. The mothers, Mrs. Eileen Moon, left, and Mrs. Kathleen Robie, last week gave birth to daughters to set a new record at Columbia Maternity Hospital. Mrs. Moon's youngster, whom she named Carol, was born on March 29, while Mrs. Robie's new daughter Nancy Lee first saw the light of day on April 1. This same thing happened in July 1937 when Mrs. Robie gave birth to a girl and a few hours later Mrs. Moon's baby, a boy, arrived

  • Digital ID: (digital file from original negative) hec 26626 http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.26626
  • Reproduction Number: LC-DIG-hec-26626 (digital file from original negative)
  • Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/pp.print


My mom is the baby on the right.  I have to say, genealogy is doing well in the digital age!

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Three things....

The theme for this week's Texture Tuesday over at Kim Klassen's Cafe is "Three."  I tried to play with this idea, but everything I came up with seemed so trite and clichéd.  That's not to say that my solution isn't any of that, but it suited me -- and that's all that matters.....

I thought of three heirlooms that have come down to me from my great-grandfather, Abel Perminter Lynch, who was born in Rutherford County, North Carolina on 13 January 1859. They are: a prayer book, a pen, and a wonderful tin box, which, according to family lore, once held cash that his father buried for safekeeping during the civil war.
Click here to see all the wonderful images over at Kim Klassen's Texture Tuesday party!

For those who are interested, I used three of Kim's beautiful textures on this image: "canvas back" (color burn @54%), "warm grunge" (overlay @ 60%), and "pourvous" (overlay @100%).  I happen to like the warm color and distressed, vintage look you get with a heavy hand on the textures, although some might think it is overdone.  I'm curious -- am I alone in this?

Back to Abel.... Here he is with his twin daughters, Eileen and Kathleen.  My grandmother was Kathleen, and I don't know which one she is in this picture since they were identical twins.
I love this picture of Abel with his girls:  he looks so glum, yet resigned to his fate.  You see, he was 60 and his wife, Jessie Lee (Seabolt) was 45 when the twins were born.  Jessie and Abel were just about to retire to the good life down in Florida, when doctors doing gall bladder surgery discovered that she was pregnant.  In 1919, that was practically a death sentence, so they sewed her up and sent her home.  They moved back in with Jessie's family in Tennessee, where she made a gown for the baby's burial and prepared for the end.  Much to their surprise, "the baby" turned out to be healthy twins; everyone survived, and Jessie and Abel had to scramble to find clothes and cancel their retirement plans so they could raise those babies!

For years, my great-aunt Eileen wanted to be on the "What's My Line" TV show.  Her line was that she was the middle child:  her brother was 25 years older than she was, and her sister was 25 minutes younger....

I made this wall hanging for my grandmother a year or so before she died.  She and her twin sister (or "sin twister") were very close, as you might expect, and in typical twin fashion, dressed alike, had their children days apart, often even bought the same furniture without knowing that the other had done the same.  Both were very active in international causes (in fact, a faculty office at the Johns Hopkins University's Bologna Center is named for them) and they both loved family history.  My grandmother was my genealogy buddy and inspiration, and I miss her.

Thursday, June 2, 2011

Tales of an old cattle wrangler...

William Francis Robie was certainly a storyteller.  I remember one time when I was just a very little girl, and we were walking around his family farm in Charles County, Maryland.  He pointed toward an old tree stump we could see in the distance up on a knoll.  "That," he said solemnly, "was where I was born."  We walked a bit further.  "Yep," he continued, "it was a dark and stormy night, and the wind was howling something fierce.  Then, all of a sudden there was a giant clap of thunder, and a huge bolt of lightening struck that old oak -- snapped it off at the roots -- and next thing you know, I stepped out of the stump, fully grown and wiping the the rain off my matching six-shooters."

All that a young girl could do in the face of such magnificence was to nod her head, awestruck.

Pop had a way of making you feel happy and excited, and sure that some adventure was imminent.  When I was five, my family moved from Boston to California.  Pop came along on the trip to help my parents with the driving, but I think it was secretly because he wanted to go through Texas -- he was an archetypal Texan in a Marylander's body.  Anyway, once we reached California, we stopped at Knott's Berry Farm for a little bit of fun towards the end of our long drive across country.

Now, Knott's Berry Farm in the mid-1960s was a much more low-key place than it is today -- back then, it was more about panning for gold, or "talking" to plaster images of old prospectors than it was about thrill rides.  My sister and I were waiting in a line to talk to one of these plaster old-timers languishing in a jail house, and could overhear all the conversations taking place with the kids in line before us.  The old guy would say something like, "well, howdy, little girl!" or "hello there, young feller!"  Then, it was our turn, and he exclaimed:  "WELL, IF IT ISN'T KATHY AND NANCY!"  We could only gape at him, dumbstruck.  "Your grandfather and I were cattle wranglers together, back in Texas!  You know, to this day I don't know how he managed to get out of that jail back in Amarillo.  Well, that old fox could outsmart them all...."  He went on in that vein for quite some time, and we were spellbound.  You see, we had heard these stories our entire lives, and the thought that this old timer knew them too (even if he was made of plaster) was just amazing.  I think I can truly say it was one of those magical moments in life, when you are just filled with wonder.

Here I am with Pop, at one of those ubiquitous gas stations with a pony ride, somewhere in the middle of the country.

Pop, as one of those plaster old-timers at Calico
branching out--boots


My grandfather was an expert at making all his children and grandchildren feel that they were the most precious thing in the world to him.  At Thanksgiving, Pop would always take me aside, fingers on his lips:  "Shhh, don't tell anyone..... I've saved the best part of the turkey for you," and pop some morsel into my mouth.  Of course, he did the same thing for everyone else, but somehow managed to make each one of us feel special.  We love you, Pop!